The Bake Sale Industrial Complex

I want to tell you about the sheet cake. Not all of the sheet cakes, just one specific sheet cake. You'll understand.

It was for the spring fundraiser at my kid's school (this was years ago now, a different me), and I had said yes to it at 11 PM on a Tuesday via a group text, in the specific voice you use when you have already said yes before you've finished reading the sentence. "Happy to!" I wrote. I put the exclamation point. I even, god help me, put a little cake emoji.

I did not want to bake a sheet cake, and I did not have time to bake a sheet cake. What I had was a job, two kids, a mother in decline, a husband whose idea of contributing was asking me where the Tupperware was, and a standing commitment to three other things that week, one of which involved a hot glue gun.

I bought the cake at Costco.

I did not tell anyone. I transferred it to one of my own pans (a pan I specifically owned for the purpose of transferring Costco cakes into), wiped down the edges, added strawberries I had cut up myself to give the impression of personal involvement, and drove it to the school with the windows open so the car wouldn't smell like commerce.

It won a ribbon. The other mothers asked me for the recipe. I smiled and told them it was my grandmother's.

My grandmother was Eastern European and, to my knowledge, never made a single cake in her life. She made a kind of cheese noodle thing that made the house smell like feet. But she was dead, and the dead can't contradict you, and that is one of the underreported benefits of grief.

I drove home smiling, and then I sat in my own driveway for eleven minutes before I went inside.

I want to be clear, nothing was wrong. I had pulled it off, won a ribbon, achieved what the world calls "having it together." I just could not, in that specific moment, summon the energy it was going to require to walk into my house and be the person my family was expecting, the cheerful and cake-winning and coordinating one.

I remember thinking, I just need another minute. I'll be right in. I just need another minute.

I sat there until the minute passed. Then I went inside.

That was, I think now, the first crack.

---

Here is the thing nobody tells you about the bake sale. The bake sale is not about the bake sale.

The bake sale is one tile in a mosaic. It lives next to the signup genius for field trip snacks, which lives next to the group text about teacher appreciation week, which lives next to the email chain about the PTA auction, which lives next to the carpool rotation you somehow became the coordinator of, which lives next to your mother-in-law's birthday gift, which you are buying, on behalf of the entire family, including your husband, whose mother it is.

You did not volunteer for most of these jobs. You just did not refuse hard enough, early enough, and now your name is next to them in a spreadsheet somebody else made.

Nobody ever sat you down and said, Congratulations, you are now the institutional memory of four extended families and a second-grade classroom. It happened the way all the big things in a woman's life happen, through a thousand small acquiescences, each of which looked reasonable on its own.

"I can do that." "Sure, no problem." "Happy to." "Don't worry about it." "I'll take care of it."

Cake emoji. Cake emoji. Cake emoji.

---

The first time I said "actually, I can't," I was forty-three, and I said it to a woman named Susan.

Susan is not her real name. Susan is the name I am giving her here because there is always a Susan, and if you have ever been in any kind of volunteer ecosystem, you know exactly which Susan I mean.

Susan wanted me to chair the silent auction.

I had chaired the silent auction the year before, and the year before that. The first year, I had said yes because I'd just moved to the district and wanted to meet people. The second year, I had said yes because Susan had mentioned, in front of other mothers, how "wonderful" I had been, and I could not find the exit ramp on the sentence.

The third year, Susan called me in July, and I heard myself say, out loud, in my own kitchen, "Actually, I can't this year."

There was a silence on the line so long I briefly thought the call had dropped, and then Susan said, in a tone I had not heard from her before, "Oh. Okay."

That was the whole thing.

Nobody cried, nobody un-invited me to anything, and the silent auction went on without me. I heard through the grapevine that it was fine. Possibly more than fine. Possibly, and this is where I still have to sit with some complicated feelings, better, because somebody else brought a different set of skills and nobody had to manage my creeping resentment on top of everything else.

The sky did not fall. In fact, it did not even flicker. It turned out the sky had never been the thing holding up my yes. I had been.

---

I am not writing this to tell you to stop volunteering. Some of the best hours of my life have been spent in folding chairs with other women, assembling something nobody was paying us to assemble. That is a real magic. I still do it. I choose it now. Choose it being the operative words.

What I am writing this to tell you is that if you are currently sitting in your car in a parking lot, gathering the energy to walk into a room and be the version of yourself everyone expects, you are not broken or ungrateful or failing at being a good woman. You are a person with a finite amount of hours on earth who has been spending them, in small quiet denominations, on other people's priorities. It is okay to count them.

It is okay to say, I only have a few thousand Tuesdays left. I am not spending this one on a sheet cake for a woman whose name I had to give a fake name to in an essay.

You are allowed to go home, allowed to buy the cake at Costco, and, if it comes to it, allowed to say no.

The ribbons don't mean what you were told they meant. The sky is fine.